WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
- Trump announced a posthumous pardon for Pete Rose after returning from the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit in China.
- His announcement misstated Rose’s career hit total as a record achieved in one season.
- Trump ignored Rose’s gambling ban and tax evasion conviction while praising his baseball accomplishments.
- The Justice Department’s official clemency list contained no reference to a Rose pardon at the time of publication.
Donald Trump returned home Thursday afternoon from the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit in China with plenty that might have demanded presidential attention. Hours before boarding Air Force One, the Republican had participated in a failed trilateral meeting with China’s Xi Jinping and Russia’s Vladimir Putin.
Instead, Trump turned his attention to Pete Rose. The Associated Press reported that the president said he had posthumously pardoned the baseball star more than two years after Rose’s death and a year after his reinstatement by Major League Baseball Commissioner Rob Manfred.
“I have just given a Complete and Total Pardon to the Late, Great Pete Rose, a true Baseball SUPERSTAR & LEGEND,” Trump posted on social media.
The announcement was remarkable for more than its timing. Trump also mangled a basic fact about Rose’s baseball career, claiming that his “record of 4,256 Hits in a Season will never be broken.”
That figure represented Rose’s career hit total, not his record for a single season. Even while attempting to celebrate Rose’s accomplishments, Trump managed to demonstrate a shaky command of the achievement at the center of his announcement.
Trump’s message proceeded through a long inventory of Rose’s statistics and accomplishments. It concluded with the president asserting that Rose was “treated terribly by Major League Baseball in not allowing him to go into the Baseball Hall of Fame.”
Entirely absent from Trump’s account was the conduct that defined Rose’s punishment. The president did not mention that Rose was banned from baseball after being caught gambling on games, nor did he mention that Rose went to prison after pleading guilty to tax evasion.
Presidents considering clemency ordinarily face a basic set of questions. They can examine whether someone was unjustly convicted, whether a sentence was excessively harsh, whether legal proceedings were flawed, or whether a pardon would advance justice.
Trump’s explanation showed no interest in those fundamentals. His public reasoning amounted to remembering Rose as an excellent baseball player and treating that athletic success as sufficient grounds for presidential action.
The strange announcement also came with a familiar backstory. In February, Trump published a social media post announcing plans to pardon Rose in “the next few weeks,” though he never explained why that issue had become a presidential priority.
In context, Trump appeared to believe that a pardon would clear the way for Major League Baseball to induct Rose into the Hall of Fame. But presidential clemency for Rose’s criminal conviction had nothing to do with his gambling violations or the punishment imposed by the league.
Nothing followed in the ensuing weeks and months. The matter resurfaced at a White House press conference last week, when a reporter once again asked Trump about Rose and the pardon he had previously promised.
Trump initially responded by saying Rose had not been convicted of anything. After being reminded that Rose had, in fact, been convicted, Trump quickly replied, “I’d give Pete Rose a pardon. I didn’t know that.”
One week later, Trump announced that he had issued the posthumous pardon. The sequence offered an extraordinary view of a White House clemency process that appeared to have broken down completely, assuming a meaningful process existed at all.
Even the pardon’s official status remained uncertain at the time of publication. Although Trump publicly declared that Rose had been pardoned, the Justice Department’s official list of presidential clemency grants contained no reference to a Rose pardon.
That omission raised questions about the reliability of Trump’s announcement. A president who confused Rose’s career total with a single season record, overlooked the conviction underlying the pardon and previously denied knowing about it had once again transformed executive power into something resembling improvisational social media content.
Join the Discussion
COMMENTS POLICY: We have no tolerance for messages of violence, racism, vulgarity, obscenity or other such discourteous behavior. Thank you for contributing to a respectful and useful online dialogue.