WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
  • Elon Musk now says he is not MAGA despite appearing at Trump rallies, wearing MAGA hats and calling himself dark MAGA.
  • Musk spent nearly half a billion dollars supporting Republican candidates during a midterm cycle Republicans overwhelmingly lost.
  • Democrats are preparing investigations into Musk’s federal contracts, the Department of Government Efficiency and possible restrictions involving Starlink service.
  • Trump responded that people who veer from his definition of MAGA do not do very well.

Elon Musk would apparently like everyone to forget the political spectacle of the past two years. After embracing Donald Trump, appearing at campaign rallies and wearing MAGA hats, the trillionaire is suddenly insisting that the label does not fit.

“I’m not MAGA,” Musk said while calling in to The New York Times’ DealBook Summit on Wednesday. “I’m not sure what MAGA means, but if that means sort of blind adherence to a set of policies by the Republican Party, then I certainly don’t have that.”

That claim requires an astonishing amount of public amnesia. Musk did not merely linger near Trump’s political movement or occasionally praise its candidates. He enthusiastically proclaimed, “I’m not just MAGA, I’m dark MAGA!”

Musk also joined Trump at 2024 campaign rallies and later entered the Trump administration through the Department of Government Efficiency. Now, after that very public alliance, he is behaving as though his MAGA identity was merely some misunderstanding imposed upon him.

Perhaps Musk believes he can overwrite the recent past as easily as he posts on X. He owns the social media platform, makes grand predictions that repeatedly fail to materialize and became a trillionaire while promoting wildly inflated stock prices.

The problem is that even Trump’s most loyal followers are unlikely to accept the idea that Musk was never MAGA. Everyone else has even less reason to welcome him back as though his alliance with Trump, and everything that accompanied it, simply disappeared.

MAGA has always depended on followers accepting Trump’s latest rewriting of reality. The 2020 election was supposedly stolen, while Trump’s 2024 victory by 1.5 percentage points was presented as a massive landslide.

The violent Jan. 6 insurrection became a day of love in Trump’s telling. The Covid-19 pandemic killed over 1.2 million Americans, yet the movement cast measures intended to limit the virus as the real tragedy and blamed the administration’s failures on Joe Biden.

Should Election Day be a federal holiday?

By completing the poll, you agree to receive emails from Left Scoop News, occasional offers from our partners and that you've read and agree to our privacy policy and legal statement.

Trump responded to Musk’s attempted separation with unusual restraint. “There are lots of definitions out there,” Trump told NBC News. “MAGA, to me, means something very specific, and when people veer from it, they don’t do very well.”

That response can be read as a warning or as Trump reassuring himself about the strength of his movement. Yet the midterm elections offered a blunt lesson about the political cost of staying closely attached to MAGA.

Musk spent nearly half a billion dollars supporting Republican candidates during a midterm cycle that Republicans overwhelmingly lost. He admitted the result left him disappointed, telling the Times, “I feel pretty foolish about having spent so much money and not seeing much for it.”

Democrats are not preparing to embrace Musk simply because he now dislikes the MAGA label. His alliance with Trump brought a steady stream of government contracts and the quashing of investigations into his companies, but it also reflected more than ordinary self interest.

MAGA is defined partly by devotion to Trump, but it also carries an intensely nativist worldview on immigration. Musk’s own conduct on X remains consistent with that politics, including relentless posts about race, attacks on nonwhite immigration to America and Europe and engagement with eugenicist ideas.

He has also used his platform to promote far right parties around the world. Those actions can damage his businesses, making the argument that Musk was merely acting as a clear eyed capitalist especially difficult to sustain.

Democrats are preparing multiple investigations involving Musk’s billions of dollars in federal contracts, the damage caused by the Department of Government Efficiency and whether he throttled the Starlink internet service used by the Ukrainian military. Those inquiries will keep his government role under scrutiny regardless of his latest political rebranding.

Trump, meanwhile, has shown little willingness to let Musk rewrite their relationship completely. “I helped Elon a lot in my first term,” Trump said this week, another reminder that the former political partners remain connected by their enormous egos, attention seeking power and confidence that the public can be persuaded to believe almost anything.

Musk can reject the MAGA label now, but he cannot erase the rallies, hats, spending, administration role or ideological record. He and Trump may clash, separate and attempt to revise their history, yet their loud political partnership remains impossible to forget.