WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
  • Sen. Angela Alsobrooks pressed Catherine Eschbach about an EEOC lawyer’s suspension after a sexual assault allegation.
  • Eschbach repeatedly cited Benjamin North’s Virginia State Bar finding of “good moral character” rather than directly answering.
  • The opinion argues Alsobrooks has strengthened her case for a larger Senate leadership role when Democrats take control in January.
  • Alsobrooks’ record includes scrutiny of Trump officials and early confidence in Mississippi’s potential to elect a Democratic senator.

Sen. Angela Alsobrooks has quickly built a reputation for putting Donald Trump’s nominees through the wringer at confirmation hearings. Her questioning of Catherine Eschbach showed why the Maryland Democrat belongs in the conversation about Senate leadership.

Eschbach, Trump’s choice for general counsel of the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, joins Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and Assistant Health Secretary Brian Christine among the nominees who have faced Alsobrooks’ formidable questioning.

Trump wants Eschbach, who currently serves as the EEOC’s acting general counsel, to become the agency’s top lawyer. The EEOC is designed to protect civil rights in the workplace, a mission that makes its leadership especially consequential.

Trump allies, however, have twisted the agency into a platform for bigoted and baseless conspiracy theories about systemic workplace discrimination hurting white men. That made Alsobrooks’ examination of Eschbach more than another routine confirmation hearing exchange.

At Tuesday’s hearing, Eschbach repeatedly deflected questions about Benjamin North, an EEOC lawyer who reports directly to her. North had received a suspension lasting 2½ years from Catholic University after a fellow student accused him of sexual assault.

North has denied the allegation and said the encounter was consensual. In 2017, he sued Catholic University in a case that ended with a stipulated dismissal.

Alsobrooks, a former prosecutor who specialized in domestic violence cases, asked Eschbach whether she knew about North’s suspension. She also pressed the nominee on whether someone credibly accused of sexual assault should be leading cases at the EEOC.

Eschbach did not appear eager to answer either question directly. Instead, she repeatedly pointed to the process North completed to obtain his law license from the Virginia State Bar.

Should members of Congress have term limits?

By completing the poll, you agree to receive emails from Left Scoop News, occasional offers from our partners and that you've read and agree to our privacy policy and legal statement.

Her fallback was that North had proved to the bar that he possessed “good moral character.” It was a neat bureaucratic dodge, but it did not resolve the substance of either question Alsobrooks had placed before her.

The exchange was sadly fitting for an administration led by someone who was found liable for sexual assault and for defaming his victim. Once again, Alsobrooks used her skills as a lawyer, interrogator and fact finder to force an ugly issue into public view.

That ability helps explain why Alsobrooks has openly expressed interest in assuming a larger leadership role when Democrats take control of the Senate in January. During her first two years in office, she has built a strong argument for that promotion.

Her case rests partly on foresight, including her early belief that Mississippi had the potential to elect a Democratic senator this year. It also rests on her demonstrated talent for holding Trump officials accountable, which will be a Democratic priority over the next two years.

Alsobrooks fits within a broader tradition of Black women from the legal profession bringing unflinching resolve to fights over injustice and civil rights. Their understanding of how law can both oppress and liberate makes their leadership essential as Republicans attack those rights.

That tradition includes the late civil rights lawyer Lani Guinier, former Vice President Kamala Harris, Rep. Jasmine Crockett, New York Attorney General Letitia James and Sen. elect Juliana Stratton. Alsobrooks belongs in that company, and a Democratic caucus looking ahead would be smart to elevate her.

Massachusetts Attorney General Andrea Campbell captured why Black lawyers are especially prepared for this moment. Her explanation focused on both the country’s legal history and the responsibility that comes with wielding tools once denied to Black people.

“We understand the history of law in this country,” Campbell said. “And we understand the history of oppression of Black people in this country, when the law was used to oppress them and justify that oppression. And now, we have an opportunity and a privilege — that we never take for granted — to use the very laws and tools that so many people died and fought for to benefit all people.”

Alsobrooks’ performance at Eschbach’s hearing offered another example of that resolve in action. She did not let evasive answers erase the underlying issue, and she strengthened her argument that Senate Democrats should give her more responsibility.