WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
- Judge Ana Reyes temporarily blocked the Trump administration from closing East Potomac Golf Course and halted work through Nov. 28.
- Reyes said the administration likely bypassed required environmental review and public comment while rushing toward Trump’s Nov. 15 deadline.
- The judge questioned the government’s safety explanation and ordered the municipal course to remain open.
- Reyes also plans an ethics investigation into possible government misconduct and intends to appoint Jessie Liu as a special master.
A federal judge temporarily blocked the Trump administration late Saturday from closing Washington’s East Potomac Golf Course, disrupting President Donald Trump’s plan to transform the municipal facility into a championship caliber course.
U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes issued the order one day after a contentious six hour hearing and just before the administration planned to close the course for renovations. Her ruling keeps the site open and halts work through Nov. 28.
The dispute was brought by a historic preservation group and two local golfers, who asked Reyes one week earlier to immediately stop the administration’s plan. They argued that the National Park Service was closing the park at Trump’s direction as part of his desired transformation.
During Friday’s hearing, Reyes repeatedly questioned why the government suddenly needed to close the course on Nov. 15. That was the same date Trump had publicly identified for renovations to begin.
“So it’s just a coincidence that all these things are happening on Nov. 15?” Reyes asked the government.
Justice Department lawyers argued that the planned closure was separate from Trump’s proposal. They said the park needed to close because its sea wall was crumbling into the Potomac River and presented a safety hazard.
Reyes appeared unconvinced, noting that the government had not previously raised safety problems before asserting that the situation threatened lives. In her ruling, she described those explanations as pretexts, although she said that finding alone was insufficient to pause the work.
Instead, Reyes focused on the likelihood that the administration had bypassed required environmental review and a public comment period. “In its haste to meet an arbitrary deadline, the Government has likely violated at least the National Environmental Policy Act and the Administrative Procedure Act,” she wrote.
The judge also pressed government attorney Adam R. F. Gustafson about whether the closure resulted from direct pressure by Trump. Gustafson said the president had made beautifying D.C. a priority while considering the public interest.
“Do you think a single voter went to the polls and said, ‘I’m going to elect the President of the United States so that he can redo the municipal golf course in D.C.?’” Reyes replied.
The government separately contended that the course had to close because nobody was available to operate it. The Trump administration recently terminated its lease with the National Links Trust, which had operated the course along with two other public courses in the district that it continues to run.
“What do I do if I make a finding that the course didn’t close because the National Links Trust was ended, but it was ended so there was an excuse to close the course?” Reyes asked. Her Saturday order did not require the administration to operate the course itself, but it did require that the course remain open.
Democracy Forward senior legal advisor Catherine Carroll, who represents the plaintiffs, welcomed the temporary relief. She called the overhaul “another one of the president’s vanity projects” and said the administration’s actions threatened a treasured park that could not be replaced.
A Justice Department spokesperson maintained that Reyes had not rejected one of the government’s central arguments. “The Court has acknowledged that the National Park Service can limit access to its facilities where the public is at risk of harm,” the spokesperson said. “Nothing in the Court’s order precludes planning for the development of a world class golf course to continue.”
The case has expanded beyond the immediate fight over golf. Reyes previously said she intended to appoint Jessie Liu, a former U.S. attorney for D.C., as a special master to examine whether the government committed misconduct.
Liu served in the Justice Department during the first Trump administration and managed prosecutions including the case against Trump ally Roger Stone, as well as the investigation involving former FBI Deputy Director Andrew McCabe. The government argued there was “no reasonable basis” to appoint a special master for an ethics inquiry.
Reyes nevertheless announced at the conclusion of Friday’s hearing that she intended to proceed. “Based on everything that I have seen,” Reyes said, “There is no question in my mind that this has to be investigated in some way.”
The legal battle intensified last month after the administration abruptly cut down trees on the course despite Reyes’ request for notice before major tree removal. During an emergency hearing held on a federal holiday, Reyes said she was “beyond disappointed in the government.”
She then prohibited the government from removing even one additional tree and ordered advance notice before any closure or irreversible change. The administration appealed, and that appeal remains pending before the D.C. Circuit.
Trump previously wrote on Truth Social that the course would close Nov. 15, despite statements from Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward and other government lawyers that no final closure and renovation plan existed. The apparent disconnect has led Reyes to summon senior Justice Department officials and begin an ethics investigation.
At Friday’s hearing, Reyes warned Justice Department lawyers that “in less than a zepto-second” there would be “serious consequences” if she discovered that any document had been intentionally destroyed. When Gustafson later invoked the government’s presumed regularity, Reyes snapped, “Well, you may want to move on from that point.”
Join the Discussion
COMMENTS POLICY: We have no tolerance for messages of violence, racism, vulgarity, obscenity or other such discourteous behavior. Thank you for contributing to a respectful and useful online dialogue.