WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
- U.S. District Judge Leonie Brinkema indefinitely blocked construction of Trump’s proposed 250 foot triumphal arch.
- Arlington County argued that construction would worsen traffic, bypass review requirements and interfere with emergency services.
- Another federal judge had already blocked construction through Dec. 3 while considering a longer term ruling.
- Publicly submitted final plans contain no mention of a military complex or national security purpose.
A federal judge on Friday indefinitely blocked the Trump administration from beginning construction on President Donald Trump’s proposed 250 foot triumphal arch. The ruling delivers a major obstacle to Trump’s effort to remake Washington, D.C. according to his personal vision.
U.S. District Judge Leonie Brinkema issued the order at the conclusion of a hearing. It is the second time a federal judge has stopped construction of the arch, but the first ruling to block the project indefinitely.
U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan in D.C. had already temporarily blocked construction shortly after the National Capital Planning Commission approved it earlier this month. On Wednesday, Chutkan extended her block through Dec. 3 while considering a longer term ruling.
Brinkema delivered her ruling verbally from the bench and described Trump’s construction project as a “rushed job.” Her decision leaves the administration facing court orders in two cases challenging the towering proposal.
The government has argued that Congress approved the project. Its lawyers pointed to an approval dating back a century for a structure with two columns near the proposed location of Trump’s arch.
Brinkema rejected that argument and told the government that relying on the statute “hurts your credibility with the court.” Justice Department spokesperson Matthew Nies responded by saying, “We will appeal the district court’s decision immediately.”
The Arlington County Board in Virginia sued to stop construction, alleging that the Trump administration was moving too quickly and bypassing the full review process. The board also argued that construction would worsen traffic and interfere with emergency services.
During Friday’s hearing, Brinkema repeatedly focused on those concerns and the “huge potential impact” of building the arch. She noted that emergency services and first responders serving Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport and Arlington National Cemetery need the nearby Arlington Memorial Bridge when responding to emergencies.
Construction near the proposed site would hinder those emergency efforts, according to the concerns raised in court. The potential consequences helped put public safety, not merely Trump’s taste for monumental self promotion, at the center of the dispute.
Kate Talmor, a Senior Counsel at Democracy Forward, welcomed the court’s intervention. “We are pleased that the court has recognized the irreparable harm that will come to people who live and work in Arlington and stopped the massive vanity project while our case is heard and considered by the court,” Talmor said.
The Arlington County lawsuit had been moving more slowly while another consolidated case in D.C. advanced through the courts. That case was brought by the attorneys general of D.C. and Virginia, along with a group of Vietnam War veterans.
Those plaintiffs argued that the Trump administration lacked authority to build the arch and that the proposal violated several federal statutes. Chutkan’s order temporarily blocking construction had already handed them an early victory in the legal fight.
Several members of the Kennedy family also joined that lawsuit. They alleged that the arch would permanently cast shadows over gravesites and memorials honoring the Kennedy family at Arlington National Cemetery while damaging historically significant sightlines.
Rory Kennedy, a daughter of Robert F. Kennedy, condemned the proposal in a court filing. “I believe this to be a disrespectful intrusion on a revertantly designed and tended site and an insult to the legacy of my family,” she wrote.
Chutkan was similarly unconvinced by the administration’s claim that Congress had already authorized the project. She found that the statute cited by the government did not authorize Trump’s arch and temporarily stopped construction.
“The sheer improbability that a 100-year-old statute would contain authority, unknown to every previous administration, to erect a 250-foot arch at a principal location in the Nation’s capital indicates how far Defendants must stretch to justify this project,” Chutkan wrote.
Trump unveiled plans last year for a 250 foot monument styled after the Arc de Triomphe to honor the country’s 250th anniversary. The original proposal featured a towering gilded arch that would dwarf the nearby 99 foot Lincoln Memorial and other monuments in Washington.
The plans have changed since the original lawsuit was filed. Last month, Trump said the arch would become a “top grade Military Complex/Triumphal Arch, to house, store, and have the rapid ability to use large numbers of drones, plus Snipers, on both the roof and plaza areas, and additionally have and hold large quantities of sniper ammunition and storage.”
Yet the final plans submitted publicly to the National Capital Planning Commission do not mention a military complex. They also contain no references to a national security purpose, leaving Trump’s immense arch stalled indefinitely as the court challenges continue.
Join the Discussion
COMMENTS POLICY: We have no tolerance for messages of violence, racism, vulgarity, obscenity or other such discourteous behavior. Thank you for contributing to a respectful and useful online dialogue.