WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
- JD Vance attacked Republican Gov. Kevin Stitt for urging immigration reform after Democrats won a congressional majority.
- Exit polls showed most Americans oppose Trump’s aggressive deportation tactics and believe immigration benefits the country.
- Mass deportations could shrink the population by millions and remove billions of dollars from the economy.
- Vance risks carrying Trump and Stephen Miller’s unpopular immigration approach into a possible 2028 presidential campaign.
Vice President JD Vance appears to have learned remarkably little from the 2026 midterms. Despite a major electoral swing toward Democrats, he remains convinced that Donald Trump’s White House is pursuing the right immigration strategy.
That confidence surfaced Thursday when Vance attacked Oklahoma Gov. Kevin Stitt, a Republican who urged Trump to work with the newly elected Democratic congressional majority on immigration reform. Stitt pointed to the “huge swing in the midterms” and advocated maintaining a “strong border” while admitting enough immigrants to satisfy labor market needs.
Vance rejected that suggestion on X. He wrote that Stitt’s proposal “is morally and electorally disastrous,” and “to a lot of people, this sounds like an effort to give amnesty.”
The response echoed Vance’s immediate reaction to the midterms, when he called it “gaslighting” to say Trump’s mass deportation campaign helped turn voters against Republicans. Yet Trump’s deportation agenda is broadly unpopular, and its economic consequences intensified the financial concerns that voters placed at the top of their list.
Vance regularly uses “amnesty” as a political scare word against moderate immigration proposals. After promoting rumors that Haitian migrants kidnapped pets and spread disease, he applied the label to allowing those migrants to retain Temporary Protected Status.
Around the same period, Vance attacked a Democratic bill that would permit undocumented immigrants to begin a five year process toward lawful permanent residency. He has also aimed the word at legal immigrants while falsely blaming them for crime and inflation.
Repeating “amnesty” cannot make the exit polling disappear. Those polls showed that most Americans oppose Trump’s aggressive deportation methods and believe immigration benefits the United States.
Even Trump acknowledged the political problem after the election. During an interview with Ross Douthat of CBS News, the president admitted that deporting “good people” who are “paying taxes” is unpopular, even as his administration has focused on removing such people.
Trump cannot seek the presidency again, so he faces no personal electoral cost for intensifying his cruel immigration agenda. He also promoted Stephen Miller, widely reported to be the central force behind the mass deportations, to White House chief of staff.
Trump and Miller are therefore positioned to unleash Immigrations and Custom Enforcement against still more daycare workers, teenage clerks and parents taking children to school. The administration appears determined to continue its inhumane approach despite the political backlash revealed in the midterms.
Vance faces a different calculation because he is considering a presidential campaign. If he hopes to win in 2028, he should question whether voters will reward hostility toward their immigrant neighbors after two additional years of Trump’s deportations.
The consequences are not merely moral or political. NPR reported Thursday that immigration fuels economic growth and increases the total number of jobs available to everyone.
The Trump deportation campaign has a stated goal of deliberately reducing the population by millions of people. That would resemble building an enormous vacuum to pull billions of dollars from the economy, and American citizens having more children cannot replace that lost economic activity.
Babies may be cute, but they do not perform jobs and pay taxes as immigrant adults do. The economic damage created by mass deportations would become another burden for the next Republican presidential nominee.
Vance does not have to publicly champion Trump’s agenda. Even if he wants to avoid openly disagreeing with Trump, as he nearly did over the Iran war, he could simply remain silent rather than attacking Republicans who want a more moderate approach.
Instead, Vance is choosing to advertise his opposition to moderation while facing pressure from right wing media. Media Matters documented that MAGA figures including Tucker Carlson and Megyn Kelly have urged the administration to make it even more difficult for immigrants to work and earn money.
On Steve Bannon’s “War Room” podcast, Heritage Foundation fellow Mike Howell called on Miller to “unleash the dragon” and “deport millions.” X also supplies a relentless stream of racist hostility toward immigrants, potentially distorting the views of anyone immersed in it.
MAGA podcasts and right wing social media do not represent average public opinion, which is more accepting of undocumented immigrants and more favorable toward immigration generally. Voters rejected the Trump and Miller approach on Election Day, and Vance risks discovering that copying it is a losing presidential strategy.
Are you feeling overwhelmed or hopeless right now? Have you been withdrawing from people or activities you usually enjoy? Are you having thoughts about hurting yourself, or feeling like things will never improve?
You do not have to handle those feelings alone. Support is available, and talking to someone can make a difference. You can reach out to the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline by calling or texting 988, or by chatting online at 988lifeline.org. Trained counselors are available 24 hours a day to listen and help.
If you believe someone is in immediate danger, call emergency services right away. Even a small step, like reaching out to a trusted friend, family member, or professional, can help create a path forward.
The opinions expressed by contributors and/or content partners are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views of LeftScoop.news. Contact us for guidelines on submitting your own commentary.
Join the Discussion
COMMENTS POLICY: We have no tolerance for messages of violence, racism, vulgarity, obscenity or other such discourteous behavior. Thank you for contributing to a respectful and useful online dialogue.