WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
  • Trump called an immigration agreement with the new Democratic Congress “actually doable,” despite widespread distrust and his promotion of Stephen Miller.
  • Democrats could pass protections for immigrants and force Trump to sign or veto the legislation.
  • Any agreement should avoid sacrificing legal immigrants or refugees and include ironclad protections against hostile implementation.
  • Nearly 60% opposed Trump’s deportation efforts, while 75% supported allowing some unauthorized immigrants to remain under certain conditions.

President Donald Trump says an immigration agreement with the new Congress is “actually doable.” Democrats have every reason to doubt him, but with mass deportations continuing, skepticism cannot become an excuse for congressional paralysis.

Trump made the claim on “60 Minutes” just days after his party suffered historic midterm losses and Democrats won control of Congress. Rep. Robert Garcia, the incoming chairman of the House Oversight Committee, captured the prevailing distrust: “We’ll have to see if he’s serious. But I don’t trust Donald Trump for a second.”

That distrust is amply justified. Moments after recording the interview, Trump selected Stephen Miller, the architect of his mass deportation agenda, to serve as White House chief of staff.

Trump told CBS that his deportation policy “might be too tough,” yet elevating Miller strongly indicates that the administration intends to continue its broader approach. Trump also has remained vague about what kind of immigration agreement he would support, and he has undermined multiple bipartisan deals in the past.

None of that should stop Democrats from acting. On the contrary, the continued deportations raise the cost of waiting while Trump and Miller pursue policies that are already uprooting immigrants.

Trump himself admitted that his administration was deporting “good people” who had been “in some cases here for 10 or 15 years.” Congress has a reason to move quickly if it can protect at least some of the people caught in that campaign.

Trump’s probable bad faith is another argument for forcing the issue. He may expect Congress to do nothing, leaving him free to blame Democrats for immigration chaos and the cruelty of his own policies.

Democrats should deny him that opportunity by passing legislation and making him decide whether to sign or veto it. Trump has blocked immigration agreements before, but he has never had to veto an immigration bill passed by Congress, potentially giving Democrats a stronger position.

Should members of Congress have term limits?

By completing the poll, you agree to receive emails from Left Scoop News, occasional offers from our partners and that you've read and agree to our privacy policy and legal statement.

Any negotiation must begin with one firm principle: Democrats cannot allow Trump and Miller to pit one group of immigrants against another. Legal immigrants and refugees should not be sacrificed merely to secure protections for a different group.

Reaching an agreement will still require compromise. Unless Senate Democrats eliminate the filibuster, legislation will need 60 votes and therefore support from at least some Republicans.

Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin, a former senator, has expressed openness to legalizing younger immigrants who grew up in the United States, even while rejecting a broader “amnesty.” That position could provide a limited opening for negotiations.

Democrats should seek protections for as many peaceful and productive immigrants as possible, but they should not automatically reject a narrower agreement. If Trump will sign meaningful protections for any group, accepting that progress could be preferable to leaving everyone exposed.

Those protections, however, must be ironclad. Miller and Mullin would oversee implementation, and the administration has repeatedly closed parts of the legal immigration system, including the green card lottery, simply because it opposed them.

Democrats cannot trade away protections that already exist in exchange for promises the administration might not honor. Broader reforms should make legal immigration easier and create a viable alternative to illegal immigration, rather than closing legal pathways while offering uncertain relief elsewhere.

Trump has reiterated his support for a voter identification law, which could become part of negotiations if legalization protections are actually implemented. Compromise is possible without allowing the administration to sell out one immigrant community for another.

Some Democrats may resist giving Trump a legislative victory as he approaches the end of his presidency. That concern should carry less weight than the opportunity for the new Congress to demonstrate that Democratic victories can produce concrete change.

There is also a political contrast with Vice President JD Vance, who said after the election that he opposed anything resembling “amnesty” and wanted immigrants pushed out, with greater attention on their employers. If Vance rejects a popular agreement supported by Trump, that opposition could damage his 2028 candidacy against a Democrat.

The public support for legalization gives Democrats another reason to proceed. Preliminary data showed nearly 60% of voters opposed Trump’s deportation campaign, while a July Gallup poll found that 75% supported allowing some unauthorized immigrants to remain if they met certain requirements.

Congress should pursue a policy that is popular and could protect people from an ongoing deportation campaign. Democrats cannot trust Trump, but they can force him to reveal whether his talk of a deal means anything at all.

David J. Bier is director of immigration studies at the Cato Institute. Irina D. Manta is a senior fellow in the Robert A. Levy Center for Constitutional Studies at the Cato Institute.