WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
- Trump answered Yamiche Alcindor’s question about federal spending and White House renovations with a racist personal attack.
- Trump said $900 million in White House renovation spending was “peanuts” and claimed Alcindor would not notice broken windows.
- A cited Economist and YouGov poll placed Trump’s approval among Black people at 15%, while 70% said he did not care about them.
- The opinion argues that Trump’s repeated racist attacks must be challenged rather than normalized through silence or appeasement.
President Donald Trump responded to a fair question from NBC News reporter Yamiche Alcindor on Monday with an insult steeped in racism. It was another ugly display from a president who repeatedly expresses a low opinion of Black people.
Alcindor asked Trump to reconcile his claim that the Federal Aviation Administration urgently needs money with the extraordinary attention and spending he has directed toward vanity projects at the White House and around Washington. Rather than answer without abuse, Trump turned his hostility toward the reporter.
Trump described the White House as flawless and called the $900 million spent on its renovations “peanuts.” Then he told Alcindor: “Listen to me, I know you don’t see dirt, but if you take a look at the White House. You never notice broken windows obviously from where you come.”
That response was not a serious attempt to address the question. It was a personal attack suggesting that Alcindor, who is Black, would be accustomed to broken windows and unable to recognize deterioration.
Alcindor is an award winning journalist who was born in Miami to parents who immigrated from Haiti. Trump’s comment appeared to invoke a racist assumption about Black people and the places they come from, rather than anything relevant to her actual background.
Even if Trump intended to argue that the White House has no dirt or broken windows, the insult remained unmistakable. He said Alcindor would not notice broken windows because of where she comes from, dragging race and ethnicity into an exchange about federal spending.
The remark fits a much longer record. In the 1970s, Richard Nixon’s Justice Department sued Trump after testers with the New York City Human Rights Division determined that he was refusing to rent apartments to Black people.
Trump and his father admitted no guilt when they settled with the Justice Department. As the original opinion notes, defendants who settle generally do not admit guilt, and the absence of such an admission does not establish innocence.
Trump repeatedly treats race or ethnicity as sufficient information for judging who someone is and what supposedly guides that person’s behavior. His comments reduce people to crude assumptions instead of engaging with their words, records or questions.
That thinking was visible again in 2024, when Trump argued that having his mug shot taken while being booked on suspicion of felonies had given him credibility with Black people. He claimed Black people “embraced” his mug shot “more than anybody else.”
Toni Morrison confronted this kind of racist thinking in a 1990s essay calling out those who slander Black people as an “irrational, emotional, lunatic people.” Trump’s response to Alcindor similarly portrayed Blackness as emerging from brokenness and treated a Black journalist as unqualified to question his palace spending.
Trump claimed the White House renovations were proceeding successfully because he has “talent.” He labeled Alcindor a loser and told her, “You don’t have talent.”
This was not Trump’s first attack on Alcindor. He has insulted her repeatedly as the professional journalist continues asking difficult questions without wilting under his unprovoked, meanspirited bullying.
Trump offered a sharply different account of his relationship with Black Americans during an interview last week with Stephen A. Smith. Speaking with the ESPN host, whose independent podcast is called “Straight Shooter with Stephen A,” Trump declared, “The Black community is the biggest beneficiary of what I’ve done.”
Polling cited in the original opinion tells a very different story. An Economist and YouGov poll reported in July that Trump’s approval rating among Black people was 15%, while 70% said they did not believe he cared about Black people at all.
Trump had called Smith “low IQ” just five months earlier. Mother Jones noted that Trump most often directs that insult at Black public figures and legislators, another grim pattern that should not be brushed aside as random presidential trash talk.
The original opinion criticizes Smith’s conduct during a White House dinner last month and the interview last week, arguing that appeasement helps normalize racist insults. Smith’s response may not have changed Trump’s behavior, but accepting such abuse certainly did nothing to discourage more of it.
Calling out Trump’s conduct can feel repetitive because the conduct itself is repetitive. Yet hateful slanders against people of Haitian and Somali descent, along with sexist and racist bullying of reporters, do not become acceptable simply because a president keeps repeating them.
Trump has demonstrated this contempt for more than 50 years. Silence is not an answer to that record, and exhaustion is not an excuse to let his racist outbursts pass without challenge every single time.
Join the Discussion
COMMENTS POLICY: We have no tolerance for messages of violence, racism, vulgarity, obscenity or other such discourteous behavior. Thank you for contributing to a respectful and useful online dialogue.