WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
- Trump claims presidential duties prevented an earlier lawsuit against Hillary Clinton, but her attorneys cite other personal cases he filed while in office.
- Lower courts dismissed Trump’s lawsuit as untimely and meritless, with an appellate panel calling several legal arguments frivolous.
- Clinton’s lawyers also emphasize that Trump waited 14 months after leaving office before filing the case.
- At least four Supreme Court justices must vote to review the appeal, and no decision deadline has been set.
President Donald Trump’s lawyers want the Supreme Court to revive his lawsuit against Hillary Clinton, arguing that the demands of his first term prevented him from filing it earlier. Clinton’s attorneys have responded with an inconvenient fact: Trump managed to file other personal lawsuits while occupying the White House.
That history complicates Trump’s effort to persuade the justices to review a case that lower courts have dismissed as untimely and without merit. One appellate ruling went further, describing several arguments advanced by Trump and his former attorney as frivolous.
“Trump filed a slew of lawsuits in his personal capacity during both of his presidential terms,” Clinton’s lawyers wrote in a brief filed Friday. They pointed to civil litigation involving his financial records during his first term and defamation complaints initiated during his second.
Trump filed the Clinton case in 2022, after leaving office. He alleged that Clinton, his Democratic rival in the 2016 election, conspired with others to “discredit, delegitimize and defame” him by promoting “a false narrative” that his campaign colluded with Russia.
The president claimed he suffered millions of dollars in legal expenses as well as lost business opportunities. A federal judge in Florida dismissed the lawsuit, and a federal appeals court later upheld that decision.
The appellate opinion was written by Chief Judge William Pryor, who had previously appeared on a list of potential Trump Supreme Court choices. “Many of Trump’s and Habba’s legal arguments were indeed frivolous,” Pryor wrote for the panel.
Pryor was referring to Alina Habba Mildon, who represented Trump during earlier proceedings in the case and is now the subject of a recent ethics complaint in New Jersey. She is not representing Trump before the Supreme Court, though she is listed as one of the petitioners with him.
The appeals panel also rejected Trump’s argument that his presidential responsibilities justified the timing of his lawsuit. It cited the Supreme Court’s 1997 ruling in Clinton v. Jones, which held that President Bill Clinton could not avoid civil judicial proceedings merely because he was in office.
“If a president can be haled into court, he cannot be excused from suing to enforce his rights,” Pryor wrote. Trump’s current lawyers counter that being sued and choosing to sue are meaningfully different circumstances.
Their petition says Clinton v. Jones “permitted another citizen’s suit against the President while requiring respect for the Presidency; it did not require him to pursue his own claims while in office or lose them.” They also argued that the “unceasing demands of the Presidency” caused Trump to postpone private litigation while carrying out his constitutional responsibilities.
Clinton and the other prospective civil defendants say Trump’s own conduct undercuts that explanation. His record of initiating lawsuits while president, they wrote, “shows that, in Trump’s repeated estimation, filing civil suits does not interfere with his presidential duties.”
They also noted that Trump waited another 14 months after leaving office before filing the Clinton lawsuit. Even apart from the dispute over timing, their brief said, “all of Trump’s claims resoundingly failed on the merits.”
Trump’s lawyers have attempted to present the case as an issue with broad consequences, writing that it “affects every future President.” Clinton’s attorneys rejected that framing, arguing that no previous president has raised the question Trump now wants the Supreme Court to consider.
“This one-off case does not merit use of the Court’s scarce judicial resources,” they wrote. At least four justices must vote to hear the appeal before the court will grant review.
The Supreme Court has requested a response from Clinton’s side, which had initially waived its right to submit one. Because a single justice can prompt such a request, that development does not establish that Trump has the four votes needed for review.
The court asked Clinton’s lawyers to respond by Nov. 27, and they filed well before that deadline. Trump’s attorneys may submit a final reply before the justices discuss the petition during one of their private conferences.
There is no firm deadline for the court to announce whether it will accept or deny the case. Trump is also asking the justices to review separate defamation appeals he lost in lower courts against CNN and author E. Jean Carroll.
Join the Discussion
COMMENTS POLICY: We have no tolerance for messages of violence, racism, vulgarity, obscenity or other such discourteous behavior. Thank you for contributing to a respectful and useful online dialogue.