WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
- The Trump administration claims it can exclude MS NOW, CNN and Politico from the White House press pool despite restored credentials.
- The organizations argue their exclusion violates the First Amendment and the Fifth Amendment’s due process clause.
- Judge Timothy Kelly previously found Trump’s broader White House access ban was likely retaliatory and discriminatory.
- Kelly will consider the organizations’ effort to restore press pool access at a hearing next month.
The Trump administration is insisting it may keep journalists from MS NOW, CNN and Politico out of the White House press pool even after a federal judge restored their credentials and access to White House grounds. The dispute now centers on restricted spaces where President Donald Trump frequently meets reporters.
In a Wednesday court filing, lawyers for the administration argued that the earlier order does not require the White House to include the three organizations in the pool. That group shares responsibility for covering presidential events when the full White House press corps cannot attend.
The administration has maintained that White House access is a privilege rather than a right. Its filing argued that presidents may select journalists for smaller events in places such as the Oval Office and Air Force One based on factors they consider appropriate.
“The President, and Presidents before him, have extended that privilege to select journalists to cover small events in spaces that cannot accommodate every journalist that may wish to attend, such as the Oval Office and Air Force One, to amplify his intended messages and reach his preferred audiences,” the government wrote.
“And in making these invitations, the President has traditionally considered whatever factors he deemed appropriate when deciding who should receive an exclusive interview, an off-the-record tip, or other privileged access to people, information, and spaces.”
The government also maintains that excluding the organizations from pool duty does not constitute retaliation or viewpoint discrimination. MS NOW, CNN and Politico amended their lawsuit last month to seek the restoration of pool access as it existed before the September ban.
The White House press pool operates through a longstanding agreement between the White House and news organizations. A small group of journalists covers the president, often while traveling with him, and provides reporting on behalf of the broader press corps.
The three organizations contend that their continued exclusion violates the First Amendment and the due process clause of the Fifth Amendment. Their lawyers argue that previous court victories restoring White House credentials did not stop the administration from blocking access where Trump most often speaks with journalists.
“Twice, this Court has held that Defendants may not punish Plaintiffs for their journalism by revoking their hard passes and excluding them from the White House grounds entirely,” their lawyers wrote earlier this month. “Defendants have responded by excluding Plaintiffs from those areas where the President most often engages with the press. These exclusions violate the Constitution.”
The organizations also point to Trump’s statements about limiting Oval Office access for outlets he believes cover him unfavorably. A White House statement said the barred organizations have “no place demanding a spot in the President’s Oval Office.”
CNN and Politico have been prohibited from serving in the pool since Trump announced the ban, while MS NOW has not been scheduled for pool duty since it took effect. The exclusions have already changed how some presidential events are covered.
CNN and Politico were scheduled to handle pool coverage for Trump’s trip to Mississippi before the midterm elections, but the White House blocked both from traveling on Air Force One. A secondary print pool reporter instead provided updates about the president’s travel.
Other news organizations have declined to substitute for CNN and Politico when the two outlets were excluded. Without the pool, particularly CNN’s cameras, several recent Trump events have not received the usual coverage.
Last month, U.S. District Judge Timothy Kelly indefinitely reversed Trump’s ban on White House access and ordered the administration to restore credentials and access for affected journalists. The White House nevertheless continued excluding reporters from the three organizations from the pool.
Kelly found that the White House access ban likely violated the First Amendment and the Fifth Amendment’s due process clause because it was retaliatory and constituted viewpoint discrimination. He did not decide the pool question because that issue was not included in the original lawsuit.
“The record is clear that President Trump made the decision at issue,” Kelly wrote. “And his announcement of the ban and later remarks explaining the reason for it make a straightforward conclusion: President Trump likely banned Plaintiffs from the White House because he believes that their reporting is generally inaccurate and biased against him.”
The administration has appealed Kelly’s decision, and that appeal remains pending. Existing D.C. Circuit precedent says the White House cannot arbitrarily deny press credentials or revoke them without due process, but the legal status of pool access remains unsettled.
Last year, the D.C. Circuit temporarily allowed Trump to block The Associated Press from certain invite only spaces, including the Oval Office and Air Force One. That decision merely paused a lower court ruling and did not create binding precedent because the AP case remains pending without a final ruling on its merits.
Lawyers for MS NOW, CNN and Politico argue that the circumstances have changed because Trump has held nearly all his press availability in those restricted locations. Kelly is scheduled to consider their request to restore pool access at a hearing next month.
Join the Discussion
COMMENTS POLICY: We have no tolerance for messages of violence, racism, vulgarity, obscenity or other such discourteous behavior. Thank you for contributing to a respectful and useful online dialogue.